• When Does a Deal-by-Deal Investment Strategy Start to Look Like a Fund?

When Does a Deal-by-Deal Investment Strategy Start to Look Like a Fund?

Not every investment strategy starts with a fund.

For some investment managers, it starts with an opportunity.

A particular asset is identified, a group of investors comes together, and a special purpose vehicle (SPV) or similar structure is established to make the investment. When another opportunity arises, the process begins again.

For genuinely standalone transactions, this approach can make sense. Investors can assess opportunities individually, while managers can structure each investment around the circumstances of the deal.

Over time, however, individual opportunities can begin to form a pattern. The same investors may return. New deals may reflect an increasingly recognisable investment thesis. Capital raising may become more frequent.

At the same time, the work surrounding those investments can become more complex.

The question may therefore shift from how to structure the next transaction to whether the structure and infrastructure supporting the investment activity remain appropriate as the strategy develops.

From individual deals to a repeatable investment strategy

The distinction between a series of individual investments and a broader investment strategy is not always clear-cut.

A manager might complete several deals in the same asset class or market while continuing to establish a separate vehicle for each investment. That approach may remain entirely appropriate.

As deal flow becomes more consistent, however, common characteristics may emerge: a defined investment thesis, similar target assets, a particular geography or sector, and an increasingly established investor base.

Investor relationships can evolve too

In a deal-by-deal model, investors decide whether to participate each time an opportunity is presented.

As a track record develops, some investors may become interested in exposure to the broader strategy rather than assessing each transaction independently.

At that point, committed capital within a fund structure may become one of the options for consideration.

This does not mean that an SPV-based model is no longer appropriate. SPVs can continue to play a role alongside funds, including for co-investments and opportunities outside a fund mandate. The emergence of a repeatable investment strategy simply broadens the structural considerations for the manager.

As the strategy develops, so does the infrastructure around it

An equally important transition can take place behind the investments.

With relatively limited activity, a manager may be able to handle a significant share of the operational work directly. Investor records, cash movements, reporting and coordination with professional advisers may be relatively manageable when there are fewer investors and transactions.

As activity grows, those responsibilities can multiply

Investor onboarding and applicable AML and KYC requirements need to be addressed. Capital contributions and distributions need to be recorded. Books and records need to be maintained. Cash movements require appropriate controls and reconciliation. Investors may also expect more consistent reporting on holdings, performance and activity.

Accounting can become an ongoing operational function rather than an activity associated primarily with an individual transaction.

None of these developments alone means that a fund is required. Taken together, however, they may indicate that the operating model supporting the investment activity deserves closer consideration.

A repeatable investment strategy needs infrastructure capable of supporting it.

The role of the manager can change too

This is another, less visible transition.

A manager who initially spends most of their time sourcing opportunities, negotiating transactions and overseeing assets may gradually find more of that time absorbed by the mechanics surrounding the investments.

Who maintains investor records? Who tracks capital contributions and distributions? Who reconciles cash movements? Who coordinates investor reporting? Who maintains accounting records and works with auditors, lawyers and tax advisers?

For a limited number of transactions, concentrating several of these responsibilities with the manager may be workable. As activity expands, it becomes increasingly important to consider whether the same operating model remains appropriate.

The issue goes beyond workload. Growing investment activity can require more structured processes, specialist expertise and appropriate segregation of responsibilities.

The point at which this becomes relevant will differ for every manager. Recognising that investment management and investment administration are distinct functions is nevertheless an important part of developing a scalable operating model.

Complexity extends beyond administration

Operational responsibilities are only part of the picture.

As investment structures and investor bases expand, legal, regulatory and tax considerations can also become more complex.

In the United States, for example, partnership structures may involve partnership-level tax reporting and information provided to investors through Schedule K-1. Structures involving foreign partners may introduce additional withholding and reporting considerations. The treatment will depend on the structure, investments and investors involved, making appropriate legal and tax advice important.

Regulatory requirements, investor due diligence and AML and KYC obligations can also vary according to factors such as the type of vehicle, investor base, investment manager and jurisdictions involved.

Establishing a fund does not remove this complexity. Appointing a fund administrator also does not replace legal counsel, tax advisers, auditors or other specialist providers.

Instead, as an investment strategy develops, these providers can form part of a broader operating framework around the manager, with responsibilities allocated according to the expertise required.

For managers accustomed to handling much of the process directly, recognising where specialist support may be appropriate can therefore be an important part of assessing the next stage of the strategy.

When does a fund become worth considering?

There is no universal number of deals, investors or assets at which a deal-by-deal strategy should become a fund. Nor is a fund inherently more sophisticated or appropriate simply because investment activity has increased.

A more useful question is whether the characteristics of that activity have changed.

Are opportunities becoming more regular? Is the investment thesis more clearly defined? Is the investor base becoming more consistent? Has raising capital separately for each transaction become a practical constraint?

The operating model matters too. If administration, accounting, investor reporting, onboarding and coordination with professional advisers are becoming significant parts of day-to-day activity, it may be appropriate to reassess the infrastructure supporting the strategy.

None of these factors automatically points to a fund. They may, however, provide a reason to step back from the next transaction and consider the investment structure and operating model as a whole.

The structure should follow the strategy

SPVs and funds do not necessarily need to be alternatives.

For some managers, a deal-by-deal approach will continue to fit the strategy. Others may establish a fund while continuing to use SPVs or co-investment vehicles where appropriate.

The structure will depend on the investment strategy, assets, investors, jurisdictions and longer-term objectives, together with the relevant legal, tax and regulatory considerations.

What matters is recognising when the conversation has changed.

What may have begun with: “How should we structure this deal?” can eventually become: “What structure and operating model best support the investment strategy we are building?”

That shift can be a useful point at which to begin a broader fund-formation conversation.

How We Can Help

Is your investment strategy beginning to outgrow its original structure?

Trident Trust supports investment managers with fund establishment and ongoing administration across a range of structures and jurisdictions. If you are considering the operational requirements associated with the next stage of your investment strategy, we are equipped to assist you in this transition.

Authors


Rafael Perez Rafael Perez

Head of Business Development, U.S. Fund Services

rperez@tridenttrust.com +1 212 840 8280